Prop Firm Hub | Page 2464 | Metals Mine

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

Anyone trading with a Prop firm 31 replies

So I accepted a Prop Trading job in South Beach Miami 44 replies

prop firm new model - my trading journey 871 replies

Attachments: Prop Firm Hub
Exit Attachments

Prop Firm Hub

  • #49,261
  • Jun 7, 2025 3:57pm Jun 7, 2025 3:57pm
Quoting montygoldy
{quote} I am not his advocate but i believe what i see and i saw trades in live as well where he entered. Also tradeify live accounts stats is also out there which is close to 200k crazy stuff i am not pocket watching that he is making millions from course heck if i have something valuable to share i would be doing the same … but this shows the possibility anything is achievable…. i have activated 20x50k apex myself as well…. this june month i am pumped to go big…. Payout - 3.5k received from topone, on monday eligible for 1.5k from blueguardian,...
when he dont has a private account Performancechart long term (3 years, 5, 10 ... maybe one year ok with thousands of trades , but still more risky) with a good bigger broker , i would not trust him at all. its to easy to fake all this , often working together with prop and brokers to fake good wins or using money from selling courses to buy a lot of accounts and present best for use as marketing .

so funny how easy it is to cheat even experienced traders with so easy methods. always works, thats why its done so often again and again.

you really dont know all the methods how they can cheat, you often post about such people... at least you are sucessfull and dont get to much problems by believe in such fakes... but other can get really hit with this bullshit.
  • #49,262
  • Jun 7, 2025 5:18pm Jun 7, 2025 5:18pm
Quoting Trader191
{quote} when he dont has a private account Performancechart long term (3 years, 5, 10 ... maybe one year ok with thousands of trades , but still more risky) with a good bigger broker , i would not trust him at all. its to easy to fake all this , often working together with prop and brokers to fake good wins or using money from selling courses to buy a lot of accounts and present best for use as marketing . so funny how easy it is to cheat even experienced traders with so easy methods. always works, thats why its done so often again and again. you...
i see your point and i believe personal account is not the only factor to judge if anyone is profitable or not… if you ask me i dont have any personal account in futures thats my choice…..::
plus i understand faking is easy but as i said its hard to convince me coz i believe my own eyes…. I have been a regular at his stream and he is a profitable traders…
as i said i am his advocate… i personally take his content as inspiration the numbers he achieved…. Everyone has their own opinion
Extreme gut feeling trader
  • #49,263
  • Jun 7, 2025 5:55pm Jun 7, 2025 5:55pm
Quoting montygoldy
{quote} i see your point and i believe personal account is not the only factor to judge if anyone is profitable or not… if you ask me i dont have any personal account in futures thats my choice…..:: plus i understand faking is easy but as i said its hard to convince me coz i believe my own eyes…. I have been a regular at his stream and he is a profitable traders… as i said i am his advocate… i personally take his content as inspiration the numbers he achieved…. Everyone has their own opinion
Hi monty , seems aall good traders suffer from being malined by so called traders asking for 1 ,5 or even 10 years of trading account when you ask them how will this help them in there trading as trading is a individual thinghy , they cant answer the question or is it a greed thing and then when they see the account stat they want you to feed them , kindest regards mate
people leave, but this thread will go on for ever
  • #49,264
  • Jun 7, 2025 7:42pm Jun 7, 2025 7:42pm
Quoting Aussi
{quote} Hi monty , seems aall good traders suffer from being malined by so called traders asking for 1 ,5 or even 10 years of trading account when you ask them how will this help them in there trading as trading is a individual thinghy , they cant answer the question or is it a greed thing and then when they see the account stat they want you to feed them , kindest regards mate
spot on….:
Extreme gut feeling trader
  • #49,265
  • Jun 7, 2025 8:43pm Jun 7, 2025 8:43pm
Quoting montygoldy
{quote} i see your point and i believe personal account is not the only factor to judge if anyone is profitable or not… if you ask me i dont have any personal account in futures thats my choice…..:: plus i understand faking is easy but as i said its hard to convince me coz i believe my own eyes…. I have been a regular at his stream and he is a profitable traders… as i said i am his advocate… i personally take his content as inspiration the numbers he achieved…. Everyone has their own opinion
Personal account is easy to trade comparitivly than prop account.
No rules to follow mostly.
To trade a prop account, high calibre skill needed.
One must be specialised in intraday scalping
Intraday only.
  • #49,266
  • Jun 7, 2025 8:48pm Jun 7, 2025 8:48pm
Quoting montygoldy
I was out of the loop on youtube streamers..... But stumbled upon this, MOFO is going for half mill on a single account and crazy part all profits booked in live streams...... I must admit crazy stats as always.... Huge inspiration either to go big or stay poor... Time to increase risk appetite..... {image}
This guy is so annoying. Unwatchable.
  • #49,267
  • Jun 7, 2025 8:48pm Jun 7, 2025 8:48pm
Quoting Aussi
{quote} Hi monty , seems aall good traders suffer from being malined by so called traders asking for 1 ,5 or even 10 years of trading account when you ask them how will this help them in there trading as trading is a individual thinghy , they cant answer the question or is it a greed thing and then when they see the account stat they want you to feed them , kindest regards mate
On the other day, when i said make 4 % consistently .... people here were calculating it will be some Millions... and impossible and like that.

It is all about what one needs.

If one wants 500,000 by making 4 % a day, it is possible.
Making 4 % a day... for long duration, say 2 years, 5 years... not possible.

I suggested make 4 % daily, make 500,000 and then reduce the risk .
Intraday only.
  • #49,268
  • Jun 7, 2025 9:28pm Jun 7, 2025 9:28pm
Quoting navk
{quote} Personal account is easy to trade comparitivly than prop account. No rules to follow mostly. To trade a prop account, high calibre skill needed. One must be specialised in intraday scalping
Profitable trader can make money anywhere.....

Plus if you think positively these rules actually help traders to become disciplined..... My risk management has improved so much since i started the props....... Before i used to blow up fast and last year i missed 47 payouts thats correct i kept the count by blowing up on last day of the payout cycle......

Now i am holding accounts longer and making nearly same amount of profits as well.....


1. Point 1 is RISK FACTOR when it comes to props when you lose you lose only challenge money or if you already got a payout then Nothing......
2. A simple math if you hold 5k personal account how long will it take to double it. I bet you'll going with 2-3% strategy it'll take too long but if you have 3x50k accounts which is equivalent to 6k drawdown and copy trade then it has higher chance to pull 1500$x3 payout with minimal time.

If you treat it as a business not as actual trading. It's the best thing happened to traders. Now they can leverage these firms to make monster money as quickly as possible.
For Example will BGF - 50$ account with potential of 1500$ payout in 5-6 trading days. There are no business out there that can generate such numbers with minimal investment and very fast as well
Extreme gut feeling trader
  • #49,269
  • Jun 7, 2025 10:02pm Jun 7, 2025 10:02pm
Quoting navk
{quote} On the other day, when i said make 4 % consistently .... people here were calculating it will be some Millions... and impossible and like that. It is all about what one needs. If one wants 500,000 by making 4 % a day, it is possible. Making 4 % a day... for long duration, say 2 years, 5 years... not possible. I suggested make 4 % daily, make 500,000 and then reduce the risk .
Hi mate , ALL is good
people leave, but this thread will go on for ever
  • #49,270
  • Jun 8, 2025 7:04am Jun 8, 2025 7:04am
Quoting montygoldy
Some news tradeday allows 3 accounts now and can copy trade... I have added them to the list they been out there for a while time to give them a shot as well.... Same payout policy like takeprofittrader {image} {image}
Now I read the rules - Tradeday has the worst evaluation rule - 30% consistency and minmum 7 trading days to pass evaluation.
  • #49,271
  • Jun 8, 2025 10:35am Jun 8, 2025 10:35am
Quoting Aussi
{quote} Hi monty , seems aall good traders suffer from being malined by so called traders asking for 1 ,5 or even 10 years of trading account when you ask them how will this help them in there trading as trading is a individual thinghy , they cant answer the question or is it a greed thing and then when they see the account stat they want you to feed them , kindest regards mate
it is opposite : all fake coaches (and we speak about coaches in this topic, maybe you missed the part??) bring your words and cant bring longterm performancechart because they often marketing different thing than they have in their own trading performance.
i would challenge you on your text any day , even any discussion anywhere... because with this arguments you cant win.

and what you total forget, we speak with Patrick Wieland about one who sells coaching and faked a lot in history ... that's why needs to be shown when you judge someone like this. (and any trader who know about risk management would do so!)... we don't speak about someone faking in forum... for example no one care about your performance, nobody would anytime ask you about this .... because nobody care about you are real or fake winner when you dont sell coaching or other.
nobody is also asking monty about his performance proof or performamcechart... of course can all be fake , but he dont sell something.

i would not believe you that you are knowing about risk management at the moment (because risk management is such a basic thing) , when you really dont know at least how to find out that Coaches (or other Sellers) dont fake (its basic rule number one for risk management in choosing coaches, to know is he a winning trader , a bad trader or a faker and knowing how they fake should be easy as experienced trader) . i cant teach you here the basics, but with your words you show big problem in understanding some parts here ... and i only judge what you write here.

maybe this are hard words for you.... but your text really is something only bad coaches and some bad traders write again and again and again (and in general you never should asked for this in your situation, or do you sell something?).
  • #49,272
  • Jun 8, 2025 10:44am Jun 8, 2025 10:44am
Quoting Trader191
{quote} it is opposite : all fake coaches (and we speak about coaches in this topic, maybe you missed the part??) bring your words and cant bring longterm performancechart because they often marketing different thing than they have in their own trading performance. i would challenge you on your text any day , even any discussion anywhere... because with this arguments you cant win. and what you total forget, we speak with Patrick Wieland about one who sells coaching and faked a lot in history ... that's why needs to be shown when you judge someone...
The result matters. He amassed quite lot of money even from worst prop firms.

He says he improved on Risk management compared to 2024.

I am sure he is on a vertical growth path.

Having said, it is not only the path available, but there are many options.

As i said, try 3 to 4 % every day with a 500 dollar account. Reduce it to 2 % growth per day at some time.
Reduce it to 0.5 % after sometime.
Intraday only.
  • #49,273
  • Jun 8, 2025 10:54am Jun 8, 2025 10:54am
Quoting navk
{quote} The result matters. He amassed quite lot of money even from worst prop firms. He says he improved on Risk management compared to 2024. I am sure he is on a vertical growth path. Having said, it is not only the path available, but there are many options. As i said, try 3 to 4 % every day with a 500 dollar account. Reduce it to 2 % growth per day at some time. Reduce it to 0.5 % after sometime.
ah no, i dont do prop, opportunity costs much to big for me and i like more bigger wins, same like you say... more easy without rules.

what i i wrote was about risk management in general. risk management dont stop by position size and stoploss , its about a lot of topics ... and this include how to see someone fake when selling something. i cant let his wrong words stand around... that topic is one of the big reasons why so many traders fail - no risk management.

"result matters" is correct... but looking at cheatable results in coach business is not what you can mean by this or?
  • #49,274
  • Jun 8, 2025 11:06am Jun 8, 2025 11:06am
Quoting Trader191
{quote} ah no, i dont do prop, opportunity costs much to big for me and i like more bigger wins, same like you say... more easy without rules. what i i wrote was about risk management in general. risk management dont stop by position size and stoploss , its about a lot of topics ... and this include how to see someone fake when selling something. i cant let his wrong words stand around... that topic is one of the big reasons why so many traders fail - no risk management. "result matters" is correct... but looking at cheatable results in coach business...
I mean Monty's results. He is not youtuber, what he says in this forum are truth.

May be his explanation about risk management in general is not accurate, but, to him he is managing risk in order not to loose account and make money thro prop firm.

This is what matters.
Intraday only.
  • #49,275
  • Jun 8, 2025 11:12am Jun 8, 2025 11:12am
Quoting navk
{quote} I mean Monty's results. He is not youtuber, what he says in this forum are truth. May be his explanation about risk management in general is not accurate, but, to him he is managing risk in order not to loose account and make money thro prop firm. This is what matters.
ah you miss maybe a point, all i wrote was about this coach and coaching in general and risk management. nothing about other traders who dont sell something.

sorry, when it was maybe not easy to see this way, i thought i included the difference visible in my text (but english is not my nativ language, so maybe i write bad to understand English ). i mentioned only that it is not important to see performance chart from someone who dont sell something (here i mentioned monty only as example ...).
  • #49,276
  • Jun 8, 2025 11:15am Jun 8, 2025 11:15am
If one is not doing futures prop firms, but doing prop firm forex ( with FTMO ) or personal 500 dollar account, then what a trader needs is a 20 pip per day profitable trading system.

If you find that and happy with 20 pip per day, your growth would be exponential.
Intraday only.
  • #49,277
  • Jun 8, 2025 11:36am Jun 8, 2025 11:36am
Quoting navk
If one is not doing futures prop firms, but doing prop firm forex ( with FTMO ) or personal 500 dollar account, then what a trader needs is a 20 pip per day profitable trading system. If you find that and happy with 20 pip per day, your growth would be exponential.
20 pip a day system will die fast when you scale it. The only systems that can survive all markets and liquidity issues are ones that are not tighten on stops and are gathering larger moves in the market. For example, 100 points on an index or 80 pips on eurusd. This is what is needed to scale trading and not have negative effects as you grow.

One issue is all these fake influencer have painted wrong picture of what trading is at retail level. No one has made 15 trades on gold during NFP and made 80k profit (as an example i saw by one african influencer).

It is far harder to make an income to afford luxury from trading than selling the dream of trading. If you make money to afford luxury purely from trading most likely you are not spending it on luxury until you have done the appropriate wealth building exercises (ETF's, mutual funds, bonds, real estate, other businesses). If someone is spending trading gains on luxury only then they will be bankrupt fast.
  • #49,278
  • Jun 8, 2025 12:11pm Jun 8, 2025 12:11pm
Quoting failinforex
{quote} Now I read the rules - Tradeday has the worst evaluation rule - 30% consistency and minmum 7 trading days to pass evaluation.
yep but their payout policy is like takeprofitrader daily..
Extreme gut feeling trader
  • #49,279
  • Jun 8, 2025 1:47pm Jun 8, 2025 1:47pm
Quoting navk
If one is not doing futures prop firms, but doing prop firm forex ( with FTMO ) or personal 500 dollar account, then what a trader needs is a 20 pip per day profitable trading system. If you find that and happy with 20 pip per day, your growth would be exponential.
can you explain more the 20pips idea? i mean on ftmo you can go to 400k and then more..
...I Bet You Ain't Never Seen A Donkey Fly!
  • #49,280
  • Jun 8, 2025 2:32pm Jun 8, 2025 2:32pm
Quoting Trader191
{quote} it is opposite : all fake coaches (and we speak about coaches in this topic, maybe you missed the part??) bring your words and cant bring longterm performancechart because they often marketing different thing than they have in their own trading performance. i would challenge you on your text any day , even any discussion anywhere... because with this arguments you cant win. and what you total forget, we speak with Patrick Wieland about one who sells coaching and faked a lot in history ... that's why needs to be shown when you judge someone...
you poor thing is it something i said
people leave, but this thread will go on for ever
49 traders viewing now