Thank you for your answer. About point 1), Why is it bad if we see lower low? It is is in a down trend ND is even stronger, isn't it? What does NR3 mean? Can't it be possible that this bar is testing the very wide spread up bar at the end of the ...

vsa with Malcolm

Wowww! Excellent your analysis V_2008! On my side, I was a bit surprised by that move because I entered at the confirmation of a no demand bar on the bar right before the stopping volume. Do you see it as no demand too?

vsa with Malcolm

Very high volume up bars — Hi, Here is in attachement a chart of GBPUSD 15m. The trend was going down and then to up bars on ultra high volume appeared. What does that mean? If there were down bars, it would indicate some strength, but what ...

vsa with Malcolm

Strange volume — Hi, I'm trying to follow the VSA principles on the forex charts, but I've a lot of problem reading the volume displayed. My broker is IBFX and many people say that's it's a good one for VSA. For example, in a down move, I'm ...

VSA with Clifton

Thank you for all your answers. I think I might have bad data. But also I don't understand why we have to get good data, because in backtest I have the same data that I've received during live trading. This is really something from metatrader that I ...

Forward Trading and Backtesting difference

All your exampless are really nice Clifton, but for me the reality is all different. I'm using IBFX and FXCM, and I hardly find cases where there is an high volume bar followed later by a test and a break through supply or or support and another ...

VSA with Clifton

Clifton, Could you please again explain how you draw the supply line?

VSA with Clifton

I've corrected a problem with the breakout dots. Here is the new version.

New Idea for Sinewave Support & Resistance Indy!

Hi, I've checked the Sinewave indicator with S/R levels and I've noticed that there were some mistakes. I'm not sure of all the rules to set PB and END support or resistance lines, but here is a version that seems not too bad. This sinewave ...

New Idea for Sinewave Support & Resistance Indy!

Thank you very much to everybody for your answers :-) For sure that divergent bar is causing a lot of problems

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams

Is there anything more in the course about the divergent bar? Because the angulation explained in the book is very subjective and very often there will be a second divergent bar in FOREX. Do they say something about the spread of the bar? Do we ...

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams

I've a question about the divergent bar. What do we do if we are long and there is a bearish divergent bar and the price breaks below the low of that bar? Should we stop and reverse? Nothing is explained in the book about that? Anybody has the 2nd ...

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams

I think I'll try to do those MP's. I've never given much interest to them so far :-( I explained wrong about the news, but you understood right :-)

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams

Your rules 1 and 2 are all fine and the conditions are clear I think. For example for entry 1, alligator must be sleeping and there must be a valid fractal breakout and the AO should have crossed the 0-line is the direction of the breakout. I looks ...

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams

Thank you for your help! :-)) Nice to talk with you too ;-)

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams

But could you give me an example on a chart, where all the conditions are filled to enter a trade, but you're not doing, because of your intuition or the morning pages execercies? On my side, I would take any signal, except if there are some news ...

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams

But I don't understand. The rules in the book "New trading Dimensions" are clear. Whatever we do, trading manually or using an EA, sshould give the same result! What would you do manually that an EA base on that strategy would not do? There is no ...

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams

I saw there are a lot of EA for trading Chaos, but it is always said that they are no profitable. Does that mean that Trading Chaos is no more working in today's market? The rules are pretty clear and if we can be successful when using this strategy ...

Profitunity (Chaos) Trading System by Bill Williams