Also, even with guidelines, who is going to check the numbers? It does look like they are all using the same formula with the possible exception of Oanda.

FXCM's Profitability Report!!!

Looks like you have a PAMM acct. I think that would do it.

BB Stochastics EURUSD System 30 pips Daily

Excellent points, Mindsphere.

US Forex brokers account profitability comparison

They are being very smart. They knew the numbers were in their favor and now that everyone is forced to publish them, they are capitalizing on the advantage. No accident that the ad campaign just started. Oanda +2 Others 0

FXCM's Profitability Report!!!

Thanks for understanding. Just registered for your webinar; can never learn too much.

Trading in the real world.

I believe there is something skewing the statistics based on the trader attrition rate. Let's take 10 traders that open an acct on Jan 1. 5 are profitable from Jan 15 to Feb 17. But, by end of Feb they all blow their acct and drop off. Feb 18 broker ...

US Forex brokers account profitability comparison

Dude, you kick ass! A couple things, if I may:

Wanted: PVP indicator

After seeing FXCM's acct bal breakdown, which confirmed a theory I had; larger acct = greater profitability avg., and spending time in Oanda's forum over the years, I got the impression they had a larger % of high(er) net bal traders. Plus, they ...

US Forex brokers account profitability comparison

Thanks!

Goldflight's RENKO strategy

Come-on... do I smell collusion or am/was I 10x the hack I thought I was? Oanda @ 50% Everyone Else ~25%

US Forex brokers account profitability comparison

fxstreet

OANDA Discussion

Thank you, Marco.

Trading in the real world.

I cannot ever remember Oanda advertising. I wonder if they are loosing customers like some of the other brokers?

OANDA Discussion

I'm really surprised more traders haven't seen the correlation between high (relative) volume and S/R.

Wanted: PVP indicator

Yes, it's not clear you actually took the trades. Exactly. And, an important part of some of those frauds is never showing live trades taken.

Trading in the real world.

Hey hayseed... thank you very much for the offer/post!

Wanted: PVP indicator

...

Tadawul FX (TDFX) Discussion

video ! more video

New Mortage crisis in the making?

This is what I thought, too. Now that I've seen their price/data feed, I see where the name came from.

Tadawul FX (TDFX) Discussion

I understand what you are saying, but that attitude is exactly the type of fertilizer needed for the current system to thrive, and is no excuse for letting unethical/illegal behavior off the hook.

Politics of a US FX trader