Yes I understand what you mean about looking at correlations and other things. What I understand from your reply is that the volume to test the are is not relevant that you look for other factors Thanks Kind regards

PVSRA Scalping with Cigarguy

Traderhome I hope everything is going well I posted the question below to another member on another pvsra thread and I would also like your opinion please Hi lissenga I hope everything is going well You mention that high volume support resistance ...

PVSRA (Price, Volume, S&R Analysis)

Hi lissenga I hope everything is going well You mention that high volume support resistance are very important to your way of trading. My question is if when price returns to test it, how does the volume needs to be? You wanted to be tested on high ...

PVSRA Scalping with Cigarguy

I was thinking about what you mentioned about stops. If you enter on the 15 m and use the atr of 4h your stops are very wide (a lot of room). And I suppose that if your position size is based on the atr your position is very small in relation to the ...

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

Where are you guys place stops? Below/above the LTF engulfing or above/below the HTF engulfing? when placing it on the LTF you get wick out many times that is why im asking Thanks Kind regards

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

Perfectly explained thanks a lot¡¡¡¡¡¡

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

Ok that looks very clean, But what should at look into to have confidence that it will hold. Wicks rejections, small candles hitting the zone for example or what will make me confident that will hold? Edit I do not look at the 1 min chart, I do look ...

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

And how do you decide wichone is going to work or not? That is the problem with order blocks engulfing and any kind of supply demand that you have so many areas Thanks Kind regards

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

Lissenga what makes you trigger a trade? When there is no high volume at support resistance on the test Thanks Kind regards

PVSRA Scalping with Cigarguy

Sorry I did not explain myself correctly what I meant was when price gets to a supply demand area- engulfing - order block or any other way that you want to call it but they are basically supply demand you use any specific trigger to confirm the ...

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

Do you look for any specific pattern to enter?

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

About the SM. You mentioned that you trade similar to Gary Fullett. He trades differently than standard VSA traders. For VSA traders the say that normaly weakness are on up bars and strenght on down bars. Gary Fullett he mentions that strenght is on ...

vsa with Malcolm

Ok perfect so it can be that it engulf multiple candles. Any other thing like for instance that if the body does not completely engulf but the wicks do is also valid? For instance for engulf long the open may be a little higher than the previos ...

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

Nice thread and simple trading. I understand your definition of engulfing. But a quick question the engulfing does need to be confirmed? For example for a long engulfing does the top need to be broken, a close above the high or any other kind of ...

MTF Engulf / Engulf fail

Thanks for the reply So in your case you do not look for confirmation on the higher time frame. Your confirmation is on the lower time frame, you have setups, in this case failed test that are confirmed. So you do not use the typical vsa ...

vsa with Malcolm

so you also look for market structure to be in your favor. I tought that you did not care about the trend only if price was above below the HVZ. I suppose that you look at it in the 1 hour timeframe and in your entry timeframe

vsa with Malcolm

High guys. I'm able to find sign of weakness and signs of strength without any problem. What I'm finding hard is the confirmation. I know that the vsa definition of confirmation is if the following bar after SOS is up and if the following bar after ...

vsa with Malcolm

yes in IC markets and fxcm the big bar before was the biggest volume Kind regard

vsa with Malcolm

Can you show your 1 hour chart please I loo into different brokers and today price did not touch yesterday's zone Thanks Kind regards

vsa with Malcolm

Hi everyone Does anyone have a position size buy/ sell button base on ATR So basically you can set the atr period and multiplier and when you hit the buy sell button will introduce the lot size and where the stop should be. I have the 3 click ...

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge