Darshanag, I don't have non-repaint semafor indi and I haven't heard of such one. The original Extreme Spike indi Al provided does almost the same thing as semafor. You can use that to backtest, or even better to use simulator to backtest. Frank

Extreme TMA System

normtold, You're so right. If we want to trade the swing highs and swing lows we have to face the repaint issue. There is no absolute correct way to trade them. We're bound to make mistakes. Recovery method nicely deal with them without loosing ...

Extreme TMA System

Harry, Your recovery method is bit different from Al's. Whatever works for you is fine. I think it makes perfect sense to use recovery with TMA system (probably not with trend following systems though). But old habits die hard. I'm having a hard ...

Extreme TMA System

Harry, I think Extreme TMA is a great system, and it's only logical to use recovery method with it. But I'm psychologically retarded. I still like to trade with stop losses. Semafor was part of my effort to try to confirm more precise entries. I've ...

Extreme TMA System

Mike, Thank you for your reply. I may have missed something obvious. I'm going to backtest and forward test both of them more. Frank

Extreme TMA System

Where did you get this EA ?

Extreme TMA System

Hello Mike, I almost missed your post. I see you don't like the semafor indicator. The repainting bothers me too. I'm still looking for better confirmation for entry. But I found it does help to exit with more pips. What's your advice? Do you think ...

Extreme TMA System

Hi Scott, You're correct. Semafor is only for reference. We need more confirmation. This is the difficult part. Right now I'm using s/r, sup/dem, trix, simple trendlines etc.. Hope the seasoned traders here can provide some more sophisticated ...

Extreme TMA System

I just used the THV indi Al provided on page 1.

Extreme TMA System

You're absolutely correct. Semafor indi almost does the same thing as spike indi. It does repaint. When there is a nearby new HH or LL this indi repaints. TMA system tries to trade the swing highs and swing lows. It's impossible to pick the exact ...

Extreme TMA System

Harry, Thank you very much for the new indi. I'll study it. Also thank you for your explanation. But semafor 3 does the same thing. It shows a cycle from 3 to 3 in 3 waves. I can see 4 waves is more profitable than 3 but takes much longer time to ...

Extreme TMA System

Harry, Do you trade your indicator? I've been trading the conventional semafor 3 (5,13,34) and found it to be sufficient. In your experience do you think semafor 4 (14,28,102,204) is better? Please advice. Frank

Extreme TMA System

Al, Please check your mail. Frank

Extreme TMA System

Hubby, Semafor indicator repaints a lot. If you're trading M5 you better check the higher time frame too. EU just broke WPV, better wait for a better price. Frank

Extreme TMA System

Thank you. I think it's a very powerful indicator and was developed by your fellow country man. I don't have this version. I'll try it. Frank

Extreme TMA System

semafor indicator — Al, I know you dismissed semafor indicator but I found it goes very well with your system. As a matter of fact I think it goes well with any system that trades the turning points. Trading only from signal semafor 3 to 3 ...

Extreme TMA System

Gina — Gina, You have a mail.

Extreme TMA System

Gina — Gina, Excellent work. If you need my word files please PM me with your email address. Frank

Extreme TMA System

Al's Wisdom Vol. 3 — I found what benefited me most from this thread are Al's tips here and there. Hope they can help you too.

Extreme TMA System

mail — Al, You have a mail.

Extreme TMA System