Thanks HiddenGap.

vsa with Malcolm

hehe.. iam not telling they are wrong ;D, but wanted correct that.. uptrust and climax big differences maybe iam only one that read Wyckoff course ;D

vsa with Malcolm

Hi thats right but there is one exception in it. Tom williams mention it in book and i guess on webinars many time. if you have resistance on th eleft this is UPThrust and not buying climax . Buying climax happend on places where you dont have any ...

vsa with Malcolm

not buying climax — Everybody see difference this was not buying climax. definition of buying climax is totaly diffferent how you can have buying climax in range ? and NO demand ? thats not true. You forgot look to the left where is TOP .. ...

vsa with Malcolm

hmm — Chillypiper where did you place your stop on that EURUSD short trade ?

Daily candle chart

Oh boy — If you dont know why Price Action works and why some price action system works then learn about law of supply /demand.then you will got your answer. iam trading just using pure PA and successfuly.

Price action is dumb, and you're lazy for thinking otherwise

no coz at that bounce i was sleeping : ) so i have to be up too early and currently iam in 3trades . and today we have lot of NEWS so dont think i take this position either

Price is everything

i forgot add image so here is my reasons

Price is everything

thats true . but on your image. i cannot see any reason to stop downtrend yet. coz you get selling from Support. and your pin bar is just Short Covering. coz its on wrong place . with small tail. so not enought power to stop downtrend. also this ...

Price is everything

hmm — Buying on the Downtrend ?

Price is everything

this chart is so old what is purpose ?

Price is everything

Not same H4 — Hi, just some suggestion. If you watch H4 Timeframe in this kind of judging market you shuld be aware that your broker can have differnet timezone for market Open. check this out on one Broker on H4 TF its seems like selling ...

2b pattern

Hi, i was watching Cable as well. couple days. last week was in range or if you want call it Accumulation. that wide spread up bar followed another up bar pusshing thru resistrance on icreased havy volume is clear SOS. (btw: it was during FOMC ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

It`s not a test it`s kind of ShakeOut or a Spring. I guess TG team and Seb Manby will call it Shakeout. and some Wyckoff analytists will call it Spring.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Vsaclub — Shoot me with PM

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

big different is that V4 have rewriten rules for signals and all texts box by Philip Friston (that is proffesional trader)

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

on that post i just wanted point out my opinion and i wanted to know what he tell. English is not my First language so maybe it looked bad. but i wrote it with good intend to learn someting and i think dr.g understood it coz he respond and correct ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

DEAR FRIEND malcomb. This is PUBLIC DISCUSSION(THREAD) I GUESS THIS THREAD IS TO LEARN SOMETHING FROM EACH OTHER. SO I POST MY OPINION TO DR.G AND HE CORRECT ME, I APPRECIATE IT. THIS IS NOT COMPETITION ABOUT GOOD TRADERS OR BAD TRADERS BUT ABOUT ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Hmm i think overall you have true. but in one thing you missunderstand that High Volume up bar. I think .this bar that you marked is Effort by SmartMoney to go up (This is kind of principle- up bar closing on the high with high volume agaist ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)