Did I say that an "interpretation was needed" to trade this system? What are you on about mate? I simply made an observation that volume might have been taken into consideration when he picked the reference bar. I never once commented on what was ...

The PriceBob Strategy

It doesn't do anything to further the project here because you won't let it, not because there's inherently no value to derive from it.

The PriceBob Strategy

If the creator took into consideration volume when he picked the reference bar, how does volume have zero to do with the system?

The PriceBob Strategy

Friends can argue Understood, just as I did the whole time. Never once said we should incorporate volume or liquidity into the execution of the system. I never once mentioned anything that even hinted at the idea that anything ...

The PriceBob Strategy

You are literally making an argument, very adamantly at that, that "this has ZERO to do with volume or liquidity." You're not making a light observation, or an open speculation. You're stating your perception of the cold hard truth. This is a basis ...

The PriceBob Strategy

No one has argued that this isn't a mechanically executed method. Also to vidvads point, no one is suggesting to use any indicators. The only mention of volume or liquidity from me is that when the developer of the method chose this paticular ...

The PriceBob Strategy

Well no one knows the true reason for the reference bar but I'd bet a million dollars if you asked the creator of the method they would AT LEAST take into consideration the massive increase of volume at 9:30 and the massive decrease of volume around ...

The PriceBob Strategy

Liquidity, volume or whatever you want to call it, theres an obvious measureable increase in activity at NY OPEN. You don't think this activity has any impact on the decision of the reference bar?

The PriceBob Strategy

Interesting insight as always. Can you expand more on the correlation between lower liquidity and inside bars?

The PriceBob Strategy

I don't think the EXACT minute matters but there's definitely a time range within that specific session that can provide an inherent edge. I don't think you can randomly select a reference bar after 11am NY or before the market opens for example. ...

The PriceBob Strategy

In hindsight, after perfect market conditions, sure.

Nova Volume Trading System

Great work

The PriceBob Strategy

100%

The PriceBob Strategy

It's very hard to teach and demonstrate this kind of method, I've tried lol. However, I do think it provides the most edge.

The PriceBob Strategy

Did someone say super scalping? My favorite! Oh his style is a bit different. I like his concepts though, adjust to bracket orders based on ATR and volatility. His philosophy is that price is either ranging or trending and your style should ...

The PriceBob Strategy

I think you have it backwards. 3:1 implies you're risking 3 times more than your rewarded.

Doomed Strategy

Respectfully, I wasnt talking to you, but since you think I was I will address your point. There's actually plenty of things set in stone. There's alot of elements displayed on a chart that do not change once printed, unlike his "Swing Point" ...

40-60 rule, Trader using trendline secret method

The swing points on his chart repaint, and once price finally moves away from the last repainted "swing point" it will look like the system performed incredibly well. The problem is on a live chart when price continues to move up and up and the ...

40-60 rule, Trader using trendline secret method

Now they're too short, can never win with this guy Good trading!

The PriceBob Strategy