I think thats the hardest part for me at least of vsa is knowing when and where to ignore certain signals.

vsa with Malcolm

I agree that looks confusing and for me I was anticipating a downmove after we printed a ND on the 9:55am est bar coming into that 8:45am est highest vol upthrust bar, but I think the thing to look at is that long up bar before the one you pointed ...

vsa with Malcolm

Thanks, good explanation. I sometimes get trapped in the feeling a high volume upthrust is a definate selling signal.

vsa with Malcolm

When you say test, what would a test be for a short setup? A ND I know, but when you say test do you mean an upthrust with lower vol into a trigger area? edit or higher vol UT into trigger?

vsa with Malcolm

would you take a trade on just the break of the past three upthrusts, or would you need to see more confirmation? Like a ND or a lower vol upthrust into the previous ones like you mentioned yesterday?

vsa with Malcolm

its does match up nicely to that large upthrust bar we had yesterday at 10am est.

vsa with Malcolm

I am a little confused as to looking at triggers for shorts, I can def see the longs but have trouble with the shorts. pres78 when you look for a test for a short are you comparing the volume of the no demand bar to the trigger vol or the previous ...

vsa with Malcolm

good explanation.

vsa with Malcolm

still seeing some strength in the pound....didn't really move on the euro move down. But agree, not really going up either. edit in at 1.6299 sl 20 down below

vsa with Malcolm

I'm watching it, are you referring to the test of the hvol upbar from earlier this morning?

vsa with Malcolm

this bad news = someone wanted to buy big cheaper? .....possibly...

vsa with Malcolm

nice, I like number two...good idea.

Auction Market Theory and Market Profile

Do you feel as if profiles should be looked at in multiple start times? Starting to do this more, sometimes I feel it throws me off, but as your post above could show when done right it shows the true direction of the market.

Auction Market Theory and Market Profile

gotcha, was on wrong timeframe.

vsa with Malcolm

NS or ND? not seeing the NS.

vsa with Malcolm

to grab the desktop do Command-Shift-3. It'll place a png file on your desktop.

vsa with Malcolm

I show 6202 for my POC (volume based), but thats for Pound futures. One question for profiles do you guys use 6pm as start of your profiles? I do but just seeing if anyone else does it different, sure others do.

vsa with Malcolm

HG do you have any specific post references that really outline your trigger ideas? I've been searching through all of your postings here and just picking up small bits here and there. Don't know if you have one post where you outlined it all in ...

vsa with Malcolm

for london I use 3-4, do you use 8-9 as US?

vsa with Malcolm

developing POC or in reference to yesterdays?

vsa with Malcolm