I already understand a bit better. I'll post other charts in the coming days ;-) Thanks a lot to all of you guys ;-) I really like the drawing of the trigger lines.

vsa with Malcolm

You're right. My test bar did a lower low than the previous bar and it that case we should not take it :-(

vsa with Malcolm

How do you draw the trigger lines? If you don't know what happened after my entry, what would make it a bad entry? After seeing what happened later I also understand that it was a bad entry, but doing so VSA would be only a tool to explain the past. ...

vsa with Malcolm

But why is it not a great setup? If you don't see what happened afterwards it looks like a really good setup (rising volume in the trading range and on the breakout, price making higher highs on higher volume after the breakout, test bar with 2 up ...

vsa with Malcolm

Yes, it is today's chart and an other losing trade for me!!! I'M LOST!!! After we see what happen we might say "I've to wait for the price to come back to the breakout level" or something like that, but often it is not doing that.

vsa with Malcolm

Here is the kind of trade I could take. Long timeframe is bullish. There is an effort to rise followed, after a red bar, with 2 green bars with increasing volume. Then the price retraces to form a no supply bar. And the bar immediately after broke ...

vsa with Malcolm

Thank you very much Beljevina! Doesn't it looks a bit strange the pattern of the volume? If you check the bars with very low volumes, they are always occuring at regular intervals, and it is the same for bars with very great volume.

vsa with Malcolm

Thank you very much for the advice. I'll try with FXPro. Could you please post the hourly chart for eurusd? Mine looks really strange too.

vsa with Malcolm

How can you have such a great volume chart on the daily timeframe? Look at what I'm getting!!

vsa with Malcolm

I'm checking the higher timeframes. If we look at some currency pairs now we see that H1 is in an uptrend, Daily is in an uptrend, even weekly. Then I'm looking for a long entry, but that's right when there is a new reversal to the bearish side. And ...

vsa with Malcolm

All the 5m charts for the last 6 months? You are the boss of a paper factory or what? Well, thank you very much for your advices. What bothers me really with VSA is when you see a signal like the one on the first chart. The first thing they say ...

vsa with Malcolm

How not to win with VSA — Hi, I know there are a lot of successful traders using VSA and I would like you to give me some advices on how to be a winning trader with VSA. I'm new to VSA, but I know all the different patterns (Climax, Upthrust, ...

vsa with Malcolm

Really nice thread! Thank you very much! I'll give a look

Learn to Trade using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Trading using VSA on 5M charts — Hi, Is it possible to trade using VSA on a FOREX 5M chart? It looks like each time I identify a signal and enter after confirmation, that's right when the trend is reversing. Are you using multi timeframes? Is ...

Learn to Trade using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Tom says that the market doesn't like very high volume on up-bars. In a trading channel, if the volume near the supply line is lower than previous volume at that level, price should not be able to break through supply. If at this level we see an ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

What is wrong with me?? I wish I could find only one trade where I see a selling climax on ultra high volume followed a bit later by a test and when I enter at the end of the test bar then the price do not continue its down trend like crazy. None of ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

What do we do if during an up trend we see supply coming in. Then the price goes a bit down and we see a bottom reversal followed by no-demand. What is the most important information: the bottom reversal or the supply coming in and no-demand? This ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I guess I would be more interested to purchase Todd Krueger Wyckoff Analysis DVDs rather than any VSA software. I prefer to learn how it works rather than to depend on any software.

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

I will look if I can find a chart with such a bar. I remember that, given what was written in Tom Williams' book, it could happen for a shake-out forexample, as the Smart Money don't want to risk too much on that kind of move. Shamus, could you ...

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)

Does a wide spread bar on low volume correspond to something in VSA?

Trade Using VSA (Volume Spread Analysis)