Thank you to everybody for the analysis on my previous chart :-)

vsa with Malcolm

Woowww! The difference is like day and night!! I really have to change my volume feed. I've IBFX and compared to esignal it was said that they are quite similar. I guess they are wrong :-((

vsa with Malcolm

Here is an example of comparing volume and true range. I'm showing this, not to say that true range is better, but for you to explain me what I'm doing wrong when I'm reading the volume. On the chart in attachement I've marked 2 grey areas. In the ...

vsa with Malcolm

I'm amazed how true range gives a picture easier to understand for me. If for example there is a break out of a trading range, true range will show the breakout bar to be the most important, but volume may show that the bar with the highest volume ...

vsa with Malcolm

I'm wondering if we are not using VSA the wrong way. If we look at the hourly chart, we can see that bars on very high volume happens almost always at the same time and it is the same for the bars with the lowest volume. I'm wondering if using true ...

vsa with Malcolm

Malcolm, What do we do during days like today? Do we stay out of any trade? For example for EURUSD the long term trade is down, but today it is going up on M15 (except for a little trade at London opening). Would you still take a short today if a ...

vsa with Malcolm

Ok :-) Ty KinsaleForex

vsa with Malcolm

Can we say that bar A is actually a test of the high of the bar with the highest volume?

vsa with Malcolm

I agree for bar A, because the volume is quite high compared to the average and what is important too is that the bar is gapping up and closing on its high. In the case of bar B, it is more difficult to say. The trend is down and the bar looks like ...

vsa with Malcolm

Ty Malcolm! ;-)

vsa with Malcolm

Hi Malcolm, I've some problems following the trend. It is not at all that easy for me :-( Often if I look at 4H or 1H chart and I see the trend is up, when I enter long on the 15M timeframe, then often I'm right at the point where the trend is ...

vsa with Malcolm

Could not avoid losing another 60 pips in this trading range. ND, Test, ND, ND. Didn't know where to go :-((

vsa with Malcolm

Stopped out and now short -18 pips

vsa with Malcolm

Now long after a test on EURUSD M5 with target 1.4225

vsa with Malcolm

I took profit at 1.4188

vsa with Malcolm

ND on EURUSD M5

vsa with Malcolm

But why do you consider 1.3380?

vsa with Malcolm

I think it is buying from the SM. For me there is nothing looking like a trap. It looks like the variation of stopping volume with that wide spread down bar on very high volume and the next bar closing off the low. If there is a test at this level ...

vsa with Malcolm

I can see such cases at a trigger level and as those levels are at key points the price could very well go in one direction or the other. That's really difficult to say. Is there a way to say: "Here I have to reverse", without it being to late.

vsa with Malcolm

Hi, Anybody could explain how we have to do when we see ND and one or two bars later there is NS or the reverse. It often happen to me and I often stay with the first signal, but it often turns out that I'm wrong. In which case should we reverse? ...

vsa with Malcolm