Yes

Real or Algo

NO - only because I haven't traded GU in some time. I've been trading EU. Could I have based on this little exercise? Possibly - this is similar to what CP has mentioned with his "95% of the time Price will Close above or below the Open" comment ...

Real or Algo

Shabs, give him a chance to respond please. I feel like we are about to make some serious progress and potentially a final answer to "Real or Algo"

Real or Algo

I see similarity with Shabs chart, however my chart does not include the open times that are present on his chart.

Real or Algo

No, not difficult for me to understand where your coming from - however you have yet to answer the question. Is there an edge? And if yes, how do you determine what that is? Specifically, lets use that as the example....how would you determine where ...

Real or Algo

Ok....so do tell, where lies the edge on this chart?

Real or Algo

Ty GEfx for clarifying. Much appreciated!

Real or Algo

IMO this has been an interesting debate - its unfortunate that a true answer isn't forthcoming, but I'm ok with that. If it did turn out that there was some algo running everything....that would be the end of free markets as we know it. Maybe ...

Real or Algo

Shabs, You literally provided me the answer to GEfx with your link - I even quoted it so there was no misunderstanding. What you "think" you were saying ,and what you really ended up saying are very different! Playing devil's advocate here - Is ...

Real or Algo

Hmm...two very different replies GEfx, - Ok, I get where your going with this - had I chosen derived pairs that was not a major for my example, your example would have explained it properly.....but please note, that is not what I did. I specifically ...

Real or Algo

Shabs, Do you agree that if you take any three pairs ( say - eurusd/eurjpy/usdjpy) , that at any point in time within 2 ticks, the three pairs will always equate to each other in a manner that EU = EJ/UJ UJ= EJ/EU EJ = UJ*EU If you agree with this - ...

Real or Algo

The problem I see with this type of strategy is failure to execute correctly on a trend. What I mean by this is - lets assume whatever your trigger is for a long occurs - what's the best bang for your buck? Inching in using a martingale method, or ...

Opinions and Experiences with Hedging and Martingale

Hi RickM When your stating - are you specifically calling out one pair? Or this applies to all pairs? Thanks, Almo

Real or Algo

Hi Classy, I was able to make this up quick for 5 days. If someone else wants to take a stab at making it for x days back, feel free Best, Almo

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge

I'm on the fence with each having its own identity. I believe its the same across all pairs.

Real or Algo

KK3 - The EA is able to make additional trades, by removing the Stoploss and TakeProfit (by setting those to 0) You will need to fix the logic to correct this.

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge

I encountered the FIFO error you described, but I was not at my desk at the time. It did manage to close the trade out at a profit, so there's that .... The Vertical white line at 16:17 Server time is when the FIFO error occurred.

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge

I may have picked a bad pair to test this on....but for the moment, all seems right...no changes made to your code. I am thinking however your issue has to do with the Stop Loss and Take Profit. If you use the same Lot Size per trade, the StopLoss ...

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge

Not sure why, but your comment reminded me of this video

Price action at the core = family members' discussion project

When I run this through the tester I am getting both buys and sells occurring at the same time, which is what is likely triggering your FIFO issue. You will need to change the logic so that in the event the opposite condition happens while currently ...

I will code your EAs and Indicators for no charge