Hi DT You'll never get a straight answer from these people because there are no records to show (consistent) profitability, there are no verifiable accounts, heck there aren't even any live trade calls! They're all hysterical (ooops, Freudian slip, ...

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

Ok ignoring the fact that the gold/USD correlation has broken down somewhat in recent months, the (new) FIFO 2-43(b) rule only applies to the same instrument. The benefits of holding long and short positions on the same currency pair, or rather lack ...

What do traders look for in a broker?

lol, it's the way every other market works, why should forex be any different

What do traders look for in a broker?

Ok, so NFA Compliance Rule 2-43(a) regarding price adjustments doesn't help the trader? I think you'll find it does! 2-43(b) FIFO has been discussed on these forums at length and has also been proved beneficial, the problem there is that most US ...

What do traders look for in a broker?

Which broker, maybe other people have had similar experiences.

A very frustrating day

Ah all you anti-NFA'ers, let's hope something like this doesn't happen to you, you'll wish you had NFA behind you 'cos the FSA sure won't help!

What do traders look for in a broker?

Broker should be an NFA member.

What do traders look for in a broker?

Hey Peter, how's it going. Yep you're right, if I'd known then what I know now! By the way I've got a couple of avi's you might be interested in, I'll give you a buzz on S.

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

LOL, capitalx are you planning on copying and pasting the whole thread? Unreal, this has definitely gone from the sublime to the ridiculous! Enough already, seeing as there's no chance of a reasonable discussion I'm out of here unless there's ...

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

lol exactly, that's human nature I guess, in fact I think the only person to post his P&L around here is Xaron! Actually thinking about it there are a few others who post their MyFXBook links but not many. Mind you most traders (and I mean traders ...

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

In the continued absence of any tangible evidence that they are profitable it's natural to be skeptical, especially reading some of their posts. I'm assuming you're a member of his group, perhaps you would like to oblige? It's a simple request, ...

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

None. Everything you need to make a profitable trade is on a simple chart in my experience. To answer your other questions.... 1.) Did you concentrate on technical analysis or fundamental analysis 1st? Did you concentrate on them equally? Technical ...

Pip newb with questions

lol, well let's have a look at who's building a straw man here shall we....in fact the only reason we're discussing straw men at all is because you raised the subject! I think I've presented a reasonable argument in my reply to someone else's post, ...

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

And that's your idea of an intelligent comment and a reasonable debate is it? 'nuff said.....

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

The facts speak for themselves. Did you actually read my post, or maybe you just didn't understand it? Read it, if there's something you don't agree with then be specific and state your own opinion, that's what debates are made of. If there's ...

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

(sigh), no axe to grind and no bitterness, just making a reasonable argument is all. Try shooting the message instead of the messenger once in a while Goosey!

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

I don't think anyone is necessarily trying to protect others from making their own decisions, like you say we're all adults (although reading some of the posts here you wouldn't think so!), but there is such a thing as an informed decision, or one ...

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

lol, more high-caliber discerning Jacko customers, great advert! I don't know about them being plants and shills for his service, they're more likely plants by the competition going by the amount of damage they're doing to his service's credibility!

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?

It might be an idea to set up an online questionnaire with multiple-choice questions/answers and a space for additional comments, people like questionnaires! You could then produce the results in a clear and easy to understand format with statistics ...

student needs answers to some questions

I think it's been invaluable, as have your contributions to the debate. Good trading to you DT!

Forex Mentors - The Best Investment You Can Make?