If you are reading back on previous posts, its good to go find it on your charts so you can see what that person saw and what happened. I think Oanda offers historical data for MT4. I have MT4, but only open it once every 6 months, so I am not sure ...

vsa with Malcolm

Testing for demand has been debated before because Master the Markets never mentions testing for demand, it only mentions test for supply. To me if the market tests for supply it only makes sense to test for demand. Some call the test of demand a ...

vsa with Malcolm

I went long on October 31st to which I was stopped out on November 8th. So on November 5 I was already long.. If that is what you are worried about. I did not go long on the selling climax, I went long off the tests at the low of the selling climax. ...

vsa with Malcolm

No I did not go long on the selling climax, I went long on the tests from October 31st at .9475, my stop loss 30 pips below October 31st's low at .9410. url

vsa with Malcolm

Your analysis was fine, like I said to Smash a few days ago, there is no way for sure for us to know whether even a selling climax is buying or not. It just gives us an idea. These two bars were the key (Don't feel bad, I didn't pay attention them ...

vsa with Malcolm

It looks good My chart is just a bit different than yours, the bar you used for your minor support areas, the spread on mine is higher. Basically I would label it as a selling climax. In Asia today we saw a very nice bullish reaction off ...

vsa with Malcolm

Hopefully you were able to take advantage of it. There was a setup on AJ 3m chart, I saw it but passed because the market looked to choppy for me.

vsa with Malcolm

Trappist, Schmurex and Carbonado will be soon running this thread.

vsa with Malcolm

Man, looks like you spent your visit to Asia in an Irish Pub. I will be in skype whenever your ISP decides to give you some service. Just a quick and easy scalp at Asia open. Anyone care to take a guess why I labelled that bar potential ...

vsa with Malcolm

EJ bothers me a bit.. the bulk of the volume is on an up bar, granted the up bar closes on its high which is bullish. Don't forget today is NFP, I personally would lock in some profit before then.

vsa with Malcolm

Not a big deal, but your labels are reversed. This depends more on what kind of trade you are looking for.. I am assuming you're looking at a longer term trade with this. For now its still to early to start looking at this, I would rather wait 2 or ...

vsa with Malcolm

Excellent you got it, I was looking for the simple answer of there was no selling climax. This move only had stopping volume, which the stopping volume was only able knocked the market sideways. Zooming in on the 15m chart on both EJ and EU you can ...

vsa with Malcolm

4h and 12h, I still need some work on my higher time frames so I don't discuss them often. Every now and then I throw something out there but its usually pretty obvious.

vsa with Malcolm

Your last sentence really sums it up, there is a lot of variation in how people trade.. Even a lot of variations with how people trade VSA. I see VSA as more of emphasis on PA and S/R is a by product of VSA. AU chart to explain. The volume shows me ...

vsa with Malcolm

What I meant was that the downtrend on the higher time frame was not the reason I was looking for on why Euro dropped. I will give my interpretation of the events later today or tomorrow, people have expressed interest on being given a chart to ...

vsa with Malcolm

Aldo makes 1 pip per hour.. hmm that is 24 pips a day 5 days a week at 52 weeks a year. Aldo makes 6240 pips a year. Good job!

vsa with Malcolm

Anyone care to take a whack at why the Euro fell instead of pushing through? And No, the down trend on the higher timeframes doesn't count!

vsa with Malcolm

Intraday trades I tend to use Pivots for profit levels, unless volume tells me to get out sooner. VSA is meant to be a trending system. Think of VSA as an early warning detection system that the trend will change. Now how I implement this is that ...

vsa with Malcolm

UJ looks to be setting its self up for a move. Volume seems to be at the top of the triangle.

vsa with Malcolm

To be honest I am not sure, I have only read MTM. I think there was a post from someone on this thread saying what you said about how they were the same book except that MTM had tradeguider charts. If you already have Undeclared Secrets then I ...

vsa with Malcolm