[quote=diceman555;5531394] LOL !

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

Thats what I'm saying, read the post again.

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

With this method you can check later with the post time stamp. Assuming that the traders is not scalping. Scalps are more shady because of the intrinsic short time of the trade. If you count the delay for the post to be typed, time stamped, etc the ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

That method that I posted above is "fake free". If somebody goes calling his trades in real time and the trades are not scalps it is logically impossible to be a fake. Thats why you don't see it around.

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

I'm not trying to praise or bash anybody but I'm not aware of a trader ( here on FF or anywhere else) that for lets say 6 months did something like this: 9:30 AM ET long EUR/USD 1.3320 10:45 AM ET closing position for +32 pips 10:56 AM ET Short ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

That may shed some light about the reliability of your poll project. If people behind a nick pretty much anonymous on the internet can't handle the pressure of posting live calls in a thread, how can they handle the REAL pressures of trading for ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

Thats incorrect Dice. They post the past. I can scalp and post all my trades here in "real time" and it is still the past. I think 1 or 2 years ago at the trading journals a big scammer was posting his scalps in "real time" and got a "god like" ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

Nope! Just use the forums as a proxy for your poll. If they can't be honest over there they most likely can't be honest here either. Just look back at the traders that decided to post their accounts, live calls, real time trading etc. Pretty much ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

Some people are more disciplined than others because of genetic reasons, meaning they are born this way. Some of us develop it in our early years because our parents push us towards it or some other reason. Talking specifically about "traders ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

Specifics. When you have a specific, well define entry/exit trigger, it makes a lot more easier to exercise your discipline. I had 2 losses last year that were bigger than they should. And I can trace them back to the violation of my specific ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

You are using this system for how long?

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

First let me say that I respect ANYBODY that follow a system. If you really have the discipline to trade what you described over and over without deviating from it IMHO you are a pro. That said let me just point to the fact that your system has a ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

Real life is a little different because you have more data. O lot of times even with a huge amount of data you can still be fooled but you definitely have better odds. The problem with forums is that you only have what people tell you. You can ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

You are missing the point. I'm NOT calling you a liar. I'm just saying that since all data is in the past it invalidates the operation. Now if you make a call today and tomorrow it stands and if you do it tomorrow and the next day it stands, the ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

That's more semantics (trust and believe) 99.9999999% trust ( or believe) is still not trust. Now about your example it falls under binary laws meaning they are random at best. And thats ok if you decide to trust or not to trust somebody as long you ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

No. I don't believe it because it is the past, and in trading, the past can't be taken as a valid proof. I can come here and logicaly explain a trade I "took". Now it I come here and logicaly explain takes I "will take" and my logic stands for a ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

I told you already that I'm consistently profitable for the last 1 1/2 years or so. And I'm trading for a total of 5 years. I can repeat or re phrase it over and over again and you still can't trust it 100%. See how futile words can become.

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

I stick to my principles, you should not believe in me unless I give you some proof. Just my 2 cents.

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

That last statement is my principle. If you want me to believe something don't come with advice, theory, philosophy etc. Show me the facts and I will believe you. thats why I don't believe in 99.99% of people here or elsewhere including the big ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?

Oh boy! Do you really believe what people say? Go right now to the E/U thread and see people claiming 60, 80, 200 pips. They do it every day. Do you trust them? "Forum traders" have a tendency to grow big egos. Don't you think that if we had so many ...

Are you a consistently profitable trader?