HG, thanks for your detailed explanation. i totally agree with your ideas on bar A & B+B. yet for bar C, my thinking is : 1) from 393-397 we seeing professional buyers start to buy stocks from sellers in this downtrend. So at least after bar 397, ...

vsa with Malcolm

image Hi, by given a chart as above, will you mark the final bar as a NO Demand bar or a NO Supply bar? and WHY?

vsa with Malcolm

excellent materials! who wrote this?

vsa with Malcolm

thank you. before finding their diffenreces i found that even for ONE signal ,the description of the signal in the book is different from the appearance of it on the chart. eg: the description of SOW28 in the book starts with "an up bar on a NARROW ...

vsa with Malcolm

how do you know that? the codes behind them are not open sourced.

vsa with Malcolm

yes if u need PM me your email

vsa with Malcolm

Hello, I just sent you a PM.

vsa with Malcolm

For those who have read Gavin's book "sequential vsa chart patterns", why so many totally same set-up name and same description texts but with different SOW XX? example: page30(SOW14 END OF RISING MARKET) and page32(SOW21 END OF RISING MARKET), the ...

vsa with Malcolm

image

Hey...what about Volume?

Hi, Don I am a little unclear about your analysis here... first.. "a large block of selling that could NOT push price any lower", i only saw the large block of selling near the bottom, and with a little green(by the way , whats these small ...

Hey...what about Volume?

image this is a 5min chart on futures contract ,just my two cents as i cannot get VP chart now. instead, i use footprint chart to analyze orderflow. i thought that in this case, the bottom swing point forms becasue the exhausion of selling but not ...

Discussions on Order Flow/Volume

Hello,Don I have some comments on orderflow... suppose this (bullish example) situation1, look inside a bar, when a huge buying delta appears at the top , i see this as the sign of weakness, because so huge aggressive buying cannot push price even ...

Discussions on Order Flow/Volume

another VP visual question: do two different histogram bars (these two are respectively in different volume profile period) but with same length have same absolute value?

Discussions on Order Flow/Volume

Hi, Don, I remember thet you mentioned your vp chart is based on 1-day timeframe I want to know whether the longer the timeframe the more precise the information that vp chart provides? is that suitable I 'd like to put my vp chart with 5min/10min ...

Discussions on Order Flow/Volume

image why signed buying exhaustion on circle 1&2? i just see a lot of buying there and thought it was a sign of buying strength... or normal buying only appears at the bottom of a bar, if large buying appears near the top so it can considered as a ...

Hey...what about Volume?

Don, thanks for your kind reply. To be honest sometimes I am too obsessed with why a certain word appears in a sentence. i have realized that native speakers do not always talk according to rules of grammer After I ...

Hey...what about Volume?

Can i ask a language question here to confirm that i correctly understand the konowledge... what is difference between "price will tick down" and "price will go down"? does the former means the price will go down step by step? and you mentioned if ...

Hey...what about Volume?

Hi Don, i am here again .. i am reading this thread and now at page5. I noticed this thread started in 2017 and you didn't use VP chart but regular price chart with volumn indicator to analyze price exhaustion,,etc does VP chart not exists in FX ...

Hey...what about Volume?

Perhaps i was not accurate in my language, i mean do these 3 phases can be detected in some way. and I think I get the answer which is YES, you read/see the order flow to detect those signs of exhaustion by using volume delta profile. And for second ...

Discussions on Order Flow/Volume

Don , based on my current understanding, before the swing point, there are 3 phases known as climax, exhaustion and absorption (you mentioned this in other threads) 1 whether these three phases will appear one after another before ANY swing point ...

Discussions on Order Flow/Volume